They have almost everything in common...except the thing that could keep them apart. Much to her Amish mother's exasperation, Bay Stutzman isn't looking for a husband. That is, until a buggy accident on a stormy night leads to meeting handsome greenhouse owner David Jansen - who might just be Bay's perfect match. The only problem? David is a Mennonite. Now Bay is torn between her life among the Amish...and the man she can't envision a life without....

Rachel Mast finds the Amish are no more immune from crime than the people they call the English. It's been years since restless Rachel fled her family's farm as a teen. Starting with only the eighth-grade education afforded most Amish kids, she earned an MBA from Wharton and became successful in business. But Rachel never felt at home in the English world. So she came back to run a bed-and-breakfast in Stone Mill, near central Pennsylvania's thriving...

After a local journalist is killed, Rachel looks into his death and examines his unpublished report and discovers that the Amish community is far from sinless.