Sarah Kauffman sought permission from her church elders to paint murals on a few of the Amish community's barns. Each was designed like an old-fashioned quilt square, representing a piece of the Amish traditions Sarah loved. The works of art were intended to draw more tourists to the Home Valley in the struggling economy. But instead, they invited a menace. One by one, each barn is set ablaze and destroyed. Now Sarah wonders if she's being punished...

Desperate for help when she becomes convinced that her baby has been switched with another child, Leah Kurtz turns to Dr. Mark Morelli, who has come to Maplecreek to study the genetic diseases plaguing Leah's Amish community, to uncover the truth, a search that could reveal a dark conspiracy that could change Maplecreek forever.